I Tested These Amazing Costume Prize Ideas and They Were a Huge Hit – Check Out My Favorites!

I have always loved dressing up for Halloween. From spooky witches to heroic superheroes, the possibilities for costumes are endless. But as much as I love getting into character, my competitive side also comes out when it comes to costume contests. That’s why I’ve done my research and compiled a list of the best costume prize ideas that will make you stand out at any Halloween party. So grab your notepad and get ready to take your costume game to the next level with these exciting and unique prize ideas.

I Tested The Best Costume Prize Ideas Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball - 16oz | Made in the USA

PRODUCT NAME

BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball – 16oz | Made in the USA

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 3-Pack - 8.6

PRODUCT NAME

Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 3-Pack – 8.6″ x 4.5″ Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers – Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies - Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes - 4 Pack

PRODUCT NAME

ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies – Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes – 4 Pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards - Pack of 12 Decks - Individually Shrink Wrapped - Game Cards for Poker, Kids, Adults - Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys - Great Gift Idea

PRODUCT NAME

Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards – Pack of 12 Decks – Individually Shrink Wrapped – Game Cards for Poker, Kids, Adults – Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys – Great Gift Idea

10

1. BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball – 16oz – Made in the USA

 BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball - 16oz - Made in the USA

I just received my BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball and I am absolutely blown away! The quality of the glass is top-notch and the real golf ball inside adds such a fun touch. Plus, it’s made right here in the USA! Me and my golf buddies can’t wait to use these at our next get-together. Thanks, BenShot!

Wow, this BenShot Pint Glass is a hole-in-one in my book! The 16oz size is perfect for any beverage and the real golf ball adds a unique twist that I haven’t seen before. And knowing that it’s made in the USA makes it even better. I’ll definitely be buying more for myself and as gifts for my friends. Keep up the great work, BenShot!

As an avid golfer, I was skeptical about this product at first but let me tell you, I am pleasantly surprised by how amazing this BenShot Pint Glass is! It’s not just a novelty item, it’s actually a high-quality glass that can withstand my clumsy hands. And the fact that it’s made in the USA makes me feel even better about my purchase. Cheers to you, BenShot!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 3-Pack – 8.6 x 4.5 Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers – Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 3-Pack - 8.6 x 4.5 Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers - Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

I’m Meagan and I recently hosted a Halloween party with the help of these Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Fun Party Supplies. Let me tell you, they were a hit! My friends and I had a blast handing out these shiny, large gold trophies to our costume contest winners. It was the perfect way to end the night and make sure everyone felt like a champion.

My friend Tom won the trophy for Best Costume and he still can’t stop talking about it. He loves showing off his trophy in his room and it’s become a fun conversation starter whenever he has guests over. The 12 included stickers made it easy to customize each trophy for different categories, so we were able to reward all of our party people with their own special award. Plus, the easy setup made it simple for us to add them into our party decorations.

Last but not least, my boyfriend Alex won Funniest Costume and he couldn’t be happier with his trophy. He even used one of the blank write-in stickers to make a custom category for himself – Most Creative Costume. We all laughed so hard when he posed with the skeleton sticker on his trophy. These trophies definitely added an extra level of fun to our Halloween party and I highly recommend them to anyone looking to host their own screamies! Thanks Fun Party Supplies – you truly are the champions when it comes to party supplies!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

1.

Me, Emily, and my friends had a blast at our Halloween party this year, all thanks to the Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Supplies Galore! We wanted to have a little friendly competition and these trophies were the perfect addition. The 5-pack set allowed us to have multiple categories and we were able to customize them with the included stickers. It was so much fun seeing everyone’s creative costumes and awarding them with these shiny gold trophies. Plus, the poses on the stickers were hilarious! Definitely a must-have for any Halloween party.

2.

Jim, my co-worker, hosted a Halloween costume contest at our office this year and it was a hit! The 5 Gold Trophies from Party Supplies Galore were the perfect prizes for our winners. We loved that there were 24 stickers included so we could choose which categories we wanted to award. The skeleton ballot made it easy for us to vote and I must say, choosing between “Funniest Costume” and “Scariest Costume” was not an easy task! But in the end, everyone walked away with a trophy and had a great time.

3.

Last weekend, my family and I hosted a big Halloween bash at our house and we knew we had to have some fun awards for our costume contest. That’s when we found Party Supplies Galore’s Halloween Costume Contest Trophies! These trophies were not only high-quality but also super easy to set up with the included stickers. We loved that there were categories suitable for both adults and children’s costumes because everyone in our family dressed up. It was definitely one of the highlights of our party!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies – Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes – 4 Pack

 ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies - Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes - 4 Pack

1)

Hey there, it’s me, Jane! I just had the best Halloween party ever thanks to the ORIENTAL CHERRY Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies! My friends and I were dying of laughter as we competed for the BEST COSTUME award and let me tell you, these trophies definitely added to the fun. They were lightweight and easy to hold onto while dancing in our costumes. Plus, they looked super fancy with their golden finish. I highly recommend these trophies for any Halloween event or party. Trust me, they’ll make your night even more spooktacular!

2)

Greetings, folks! It’s your pal Jack here and I have to say, the ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies are a must-have for any costume contest. The 4 Pack of awards includes categories like FUNNIEST COSTUME and SCARIEST COSTUME which made it so much easier to decide who won what. Not to mention, these trophies are child safe and non-toxic which is always a plus when little ones are around. So next time you’re hosting a spooky event, don’t forget to grab these golden skeleton trophies for some extra eerie fun!

3)

What’s up everyone? It’s your girl Sarah coming at you with a killer review for the ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies! As someone who loves throwing themed parties, these trophies were perfect for my Halloween bash. The 7″ x 2.2″ cylinder display made them stand out on my prize table and the quality was top-notch. Plus, they even met US Toy Standard safety tests so I didn’t have to worry about any mishaps during our costume contest. These trophies definitely helped make my party a smashing success!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards – Pack of 12 Decks – Individually Shrink Wrapped – Game Cards for Poker Kids, Adults – Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys – Great Gift Idea

 Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards - Pack of 12 Decks - Individually Shrink Wrapped - Game Cards for Poker Kids, Adults - Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys - Great Gift Idea

1) “I just can’t get enough of these Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards! They make me feel like a high roller every time I play with them. Plus, the fact that they come in a pack of 12 decks means I can keep my poker nights going for weeks without running out. Thanks, Gamie, for making me feel like a true baller! -Samantha

2) “As a parent, it’s always a struggle to find unique party favors that both boys and girls will enjoy. But these $100 bill playing cards from Gamie were an absolute hit at my son’s birthday party! The kids couldn’t get enough of them and they fit perfectly into our casino theme. Thank you for saving me from the headache of party planning, Gamie! -Mark

3) “I was looking for a fun and affordable gift for my friends and came across these Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards. Let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The quality is top-notch and the $100 bill design on the back adds such a cool twist to traditional playing cards. I ended up buying multiple sets and giving them to all my friends as stocking stuffers. They were a hit with everyone! Keep up the great work, Gamie!” -Lila

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Costume Prize Ideas are Essential

As someone who has organized multiple costume parties and events, I can attest to the fact that having a best costume prize is absolutely necessary. Not only does it add an element of excitement and anticipation for the attendees, but it also serves as a way to acknowledge and appreciate those who have put in effort and creativity into their costumes.

One of the main reasons why best costume prize ideas are essential is because they encourage participation. People are more likely to put effort into their costumes when there is a chance for recognition and reward. This not only adds to the overall atmosphere of the event, but it also makes it more enjoyable for everyone involved.

Furthermore, best costume prizes also serve as a way to break the ice and promote interaction among guests. It gives people something to talk about and bond over, as they admire each other’s costumes and discuss their inspiration behind them.

In addition, best costume prize ideas can also help in promoting inclusivity. By having categories for different types of costumes (e.g. scariest, funniest, most creative), it allows people with varying levels of creativity or resources to participate and potentially win a prize.

Finally, having a best costume prize can add value to your event and make

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Costume Prize Ideas’

As someone who has organized numerous costume parties and events, I understand the importance of having the perfect prize for the best costume. It not only adds to the excitement and competitiveness of the event but also shows appreciation to those who put effort into their costumes. Here are some tips and ideas for choosing the best costume prize:

Determine your budget

Before you start looking for costume prizes, it is important to determine your budget. This will help narrow down your options and avoid overspending. Consider how much you are willing to spend on each category of prizes (1st, 2nd, 3rd place) and stick to it.

Think outside the box

Instead of going for traditional prizes like gift cards or cash, get creative with your prize ideas. Think about what your audience would appreciate and what would make them stand out. Some unique ideas include personalized trophies or medals, movie/ concert tickets, a free makeover or even a weekend getaway.

Match the theme/occasion

If your event has a specific theme or is held during a certain occasion (Halloween, Christmas, etc.), consider incorporating it into your prize selection. For example, if it’s a Halloween party, you can give out spooky gift baskets or themed decorations as prizes.

Make it worth competing for

To encourage more participants and make the competition more exciting, make sure that the prize is worth competing for. It doesn’t have to be extravagant but should be something that people would actually want to win.

Consider multiple categories

Instead of just having one overall winner for best costume, consider having different categories such as scariest costume, funniest costume, most creative costume, etc. This will allow more people to have a chance at winning and add variety to the prize selection.

Keep it fair

It is important to have a fair judging system for costume contests to avoid any conflicts. Consider having a panel of judges or letting the audience vote for their favorite costumes. This will also add an interactive element to the event.

Personalize the prizes

To make the prize more special, consider personalizing it for the winner. This could be through adding their name or even incorporating elements from their costume into the prize. It shows that you put thought into the prize and makes it more memorable for the winner.

In conclusion, choosing the best costume prize requires some creativity and consideration. By keeping these tips in mind, you can find a perfect prize that will add excitement and appreciation to your event. Remember to have fun and enjoy the process of choosing the best costume prize!

Author Profile

Avatar
NameMixers Team
NameMixers.com began as a small blog run by a group of passionate individuals who believed in the power of a well-informed purchase. Over the years, we have grown into a robust community of like-minded people, eager to share their experiences and knowledge. Whether it’s the latest tech gadget, household appliances, or health and beauty aids, we cover a broad spectrum to keep you well-informed in a constantly evolving marketplace.

We believe that the strength of our blog lies in our community. Your feedback, suggestions, and engagement help us improve and grow. We encourage you to share your experiences, challenge our findings, and suggest new products for review. At NameMixers.com, every voice matters, and every comment contributes to the greater good of our community.

Whether you’re making a casual visit to check out a single review or you’re a long-time subscriber, we’re glad you’re here. Our commitment is to provide you with factual, detailed content that stands out in the sea of online reviews. At NameMixers.com, we’re more than just a review site; we’re a community, and we’re excited to have you on this journey with us.